Seldom have I read anything as compelling as this first time novel of David Wroblewski. I simply could not put it down. I consider myself a slow reader so for me to finish a 500 page plus book in less than two weeks was an accomplishment. This is a wonderful story of a boy, Edgar, his parents, Gar and Trudy and his mysterious uncle Claude. But most of all it is about the amazing ‘Sawtelle’ dogs. The story is both unique and electrifying.
The setting is a farm in Wisconsin where Edgar’s family raises to yearlings their very special ‘Sawtelle’ dogs. These dogs clearly learn from as well as teach the humans around them. Edgar’s dog, Almondine, seems to be an extension of him as Almondine has been Edgar’s protector and companion since he was an infant. Edgar is a brilliant boy who was born mute and with the help of his mother perfected sign language and developed much of his own. He communicates flawlessly. But sadly there is one time when things go horrible wrong and he is unable to get help.
Every good story has a suspicious character and features the usual battle of good vs evil. In this case Edgar’s uncle, Claude, provides these elements. The barn on the Sawtelle’s farm is a character unto itself for this is where the dogs are born, cared for, trained and given that special treatment resulting in their uniqueness. The final scene in this dramatic story is played out in the barn as well as many other turning points in this remarkable tale.
It has taken me several days and lots of book discussion moments to finally accept the ending of this story. At first I was disappointed as it seemed to be so unfulfilling given how utterly taken I was with the story. Then, I was angry how could the author do this to his readers!?! I had actually closed the book at one point about 50 pages from the end and contemplated whether to finish it. Imagine being that emotionally involved that you just didn’t want to confirm the ending you feared.
I will not forget this novel and I can only hope to read something else this outstanding sometime soon.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
What a wonderful review! I have not read this book yet, though I have recommended it to several people based upon the review from the Boston Globe. I can't wait to read it and will be sure to let you know my thoughts when I finish.
I am going to take your advice and read the new Elizabeth George book too. I have resisted because I was so upset by the events in the last Lynley/Havers book.
Dotty-
I read "The Tale of Edgar Sawtelle" while on Nantucket last week. I read it in three days. I was so enthralled with the dogs... As you know, my passion is related to anyting canine, due to the remarkbable and irreplaceable relationship I have with Marco (who turns 14 tomorrow)--- my own Almondine. I too am still astounded at the ending and it brought to life so many emotions for me. And I share your disbelief. I can't wait to talk to you about it. Your words go beyond eloquence... You truly were touched by the book and have the gift to describe the richness of it without giving anything away. Amazing. Love, Curl
Post a Comment